Worked Examples in Mathematics: Show the Thinking, Then Fade the Support
Make each mathematical decision visible, then remove support when pupils can explain and use the method themselves.
Explore the guide
They copied every line. Can they choose the next step?
A teacher completes an equation on the board. The class copies it accurately, and the books look reassuring. When the next problem changes the numbers, several pupils wait for the teacher to begin again. They recorded the solution, but the decisions behind it remain hidden.
Worked examples in mathematics show a complete solution with enough explanation for learners to understand why the steps make sense. Pair a model with a related problem, ask pupils to explain key choices and fade selected support as their responses justify it. The goal is independent reasoning, not increasingly accurate copying.
Give pupils a method they can explain.
Make decisions visible
A labelled example helps the teacher distinguish the operation from its purpose. Pupils can discuss why a step preserves equality rather than memorising an unexplained movement of symbols.
Focus attention on one idea
A carefully chosen model lets the class examine a particular mathematical relationship. The teacher can postpone extra complexity until that relationship is understood.
Choose support from evidence
A partly completed example reveals whether pupils can supply and explain a missing step. Their responses help the teacher decide whether to model again or move towards independent work.
A model, a related problem and an explanation.
A worked example includes the problem, the solution steps and the reasoning that connects them. A faded example removes some of those steps. Independent practice then asks the learner to plan and carry out the solution without a displayed route.
The US Institute of Education Sciences practice guide recommends interleaving worked solutions with problem-solving exercises. This guide adapts that principle into a classroom sequence. It does not prescribe one fixed ratio of examples to exercises or suggest that every learner needs the same amount of support.
Research context: Institute of Education Sciences — Organizing Instruction and Study to Improve Student Learning.
Six principles for useful worked examples.
Identify the exact learning goal
Decide what learners should understand, such as preserving equality while isolating an unknown. A broad goal like doing algebra makes it harder to decide which parts of the solution need explanation.
Check the starting knowledge
Before the example, check the meaning of the equal sign and the relevant arithmetic. If pupils do not yet understand those ideas, adding more symbolic steps may hide the actual source of difficulty.
Place reasons beside the steps
Keep the operation and explanation close together. Pupils should not have to search across a crowded slide to connect them. Use plain language and consistent notation, then discuss the mathematical vocabulary explicitly.
Ask about choices, not copying
Use prompts such as: Why subtract five from both sides? What would happen if we changed only one side? Give learners time to think before inviting an explanation from the class.
Fade one demand deliberately
Remove a selected step or reason rather than several unrelated supports at once. Ask pupils to complete it and explain their choice. If that demand proves too large, restore the relevant support without framing it as failure.
Vary the task after the structure is clear
Begin with a related problem so pupils can recognise the method. Later, vary the form or context to check whether they can select the approach. Success on nearly identical questions alone does not establish flexible understanding.
Eight moves for a model-to-practice lesson.
Prepare a short prerequisite check
Ask pupils to explain equality using a simple numerical statement before introducing the equation. Use their responses to decide whether a brief clarification is needed. Keep the check connected to the lesson rather than adding an unrelated starter.
Choose one clean example
Select numbers that allow attention to stay on the intended idea. Solve the problem yourself and check every line. Remove decorative material or story details that do not contribute to the learning goal.
Model the first decision aloud
Explain what you are trying to preserve and change. For a simple equation, name the operation applied to both sides. Avoid relying only on a shortcut phrase such as move it across and change the sign.
Pause before revealing the next line
Ask learners to predict an operation or explain why a proposed one would work. Collect responses from more than the fastest volunteers. A brief written explanation can make quieter pupils’ thinking available.
Pair the example with a close problem
Let pupils try a related question while the model remains available. Ask them to point to the relationship between the two problems. Using the example is part of supported practice, not evidence of cheating.
Remove a carefully chosen step
Present a faded example and ask pupils to fill the gap. Check both the answer and the reason. A correct number reached through an unreliable method still gives you something important to discuss.
Use an error as a reasoning task
Show a clearly labelled fictional mistake and ask which equality-preserving action is missing. Discuss the method without attaching the error to a pupil. Then supply a corrected solution so the wrong example is not left unresolved.
Select the next practice from responses
If pupils explain and apply the method, move towards independent work and later variation. If they cannot explain a key step, return to that step. Record the teaching decision, not just how many exercises were completed.
The SEE–COMPLETE–SOLVE route
This original planning route links support to learner responses. It is not a fixed timetable: a class or group may return to a model when the explanation reveals a gap. Use the route within your professional judgement and curriculum sequence.
Choose the next task from the learner’s explanation
See the model
Examine the complete solution and explain one key decision.
If the reason is unclear → clarify or model again.
Complete a step
Supply a missing operation or explanation in a related example.
If the gap is too large → restore the relevant support.
Solve independently
Choose and carry out the steps without the displayed solution.
If reasoning is secure → vary the form or context.
Check and return
Substitute the answer and explain why it satisfies the original equation.
If the check fails → locate the first incorrect step.
One equation idea, three levels of support.
Illustrative Class VII-style lesson segment: pupils work on simple equations after learning the necessary arithmetic and meaning of equality. The exact class placement depends on the school’s curriculum. The teacher’s focus is applying the same operation to both sides.
3x + 5 = 20
3x + 5 − 5 = 20 − 5
3x = 15
x = 5
Subtract 5 from both sides, then divide both sides by 3. Check: 3 × 5 + 5 = 20.
4x + 7 = 27
4x = ____
x = ____
What operation removes the added 7? Why must it be applied to both sides?
Reveal the worked answer
Subtract 7 from both sides: 4x = 20. Divide both sides by 4: x = 5. Check: 4 × 5 + 7 = 27.
5x + 4 = 34
Write the steps and explain the first operation. Then check the answer in the original equation.
Check your solution
Subtract 4 from both sides: 5x = 30. Divide both sides by 5: x = 6. Check: 5 × 6 + 4 = 34.
Discuss a fictional error
Incorrect step: 3x + 5 = 20 → 3x = 25.
Ask: Which operation would remove the added 5 while preserving equality? Repair: subtract 5 from both sides to obtain 3x = 15. Explain the operation before calculating the final answer.
Who can do what next?
Teachers
Select examples that reveal the intended relationship. Listen for reasons, check misconceptions and adjust the amount of support. Keep the model available when it serves the current task, then remove it deliberately.
Students
Ask why a step is valid, compare your reasoning with the model and check the final answer. If you are stuck, identify the first step you cannot explain rather than copying the remaining lines silently.
Coordinators
Help colleagues review example quality and curriculum fit. Compare how explanations are presented across classes without imposing identical scripts. Provide time to improve a small set of reusable examples.
Build and refine one worked-example sequence.
Use this seven-day planning sprint for one mathematical idea. Adjust the dates to your teaching timetable; completing the checklist does not establish that every pupil has mastered the content.
0 of 7 tasks complete
Checks stay on this page while it is open. They are not saved or sent anywhere.
What needs one more conversation?
This interactive checklist is a reflection aid, not a diagnostic test or assessment. Use an unticked item to identify a useful next conversation; it does not produce a score.
Frequently asked questions
Are worked examples just demonstrations?
A demonstration can be a worked example, but pupils need opportunities to examine and explain the reasoning. Pair the model with related practice and questions about decisions. Watching a fluent solution is not the same as being able to reproduce or justify it.
When should I remove the model?
Use learner responses rather than a fixed number of minutes. Begin by removing a selected step or explanation. If pupils can complete and explain it, move towards more independent work; if not, restore the support that addresses the difficulty.
Should all pupils use the same support?
Not necessarily. Some may need the complete model while others can attempt a faded or independent version. Keep the underlying learning goal clear and review support using current evidence, rather than treating groups as permanent ability labels.
Can I use an incorrect example?
Yes, when the error is clearly labelled and the task requires explanation and correction. Ensure the correct reasoning is made explicit afterwards. Avoid leaving an incorrect solution on display as if it were an acceptable model.
How do I prevent mechanical copying?
Ask pupils to explain a decision, compare two steps, predict what follows or check an answer in the original problem. Later vary the task. These prompts provide better information than simply checking whether notebooks match the board.
Does this approach work only for equations?
The design can be adapted to other mathematical procedures and representations. Select examples that fit the concept and learners’ starting knowledge. Do not assume that a useful equation sequence automatically provides the right model for geometry, statistics or an unfamiliar problem type.
Start with one useful change.
Worked examples in mathematics should reveal the thinking that connects one line to the next. Model deliberately, pair examples with practice and fade support in response to learners. A pupil who can explain and check a method gives you more useful evidence than a perfectly copied page.
